Question 1

How do I order for custom cakes + treats?

Accepted Answer

Please complete our inquiry form at "Custom Orders"
For standard menu items check "Order Online"

Question 2

How far in advance should I place my order?

Accepted Answer

For custom orders, please place your order at least one week in advance but no earlier than 2 months before the event. For weddings, reach out no earlier than 6 months before the big day. For treats and handcrafted cheesecakes, a week's notice is required. For rush orders, text us at 219-267-1630.

Question 3

Do you have a store location I can visit?

Accepted Answer

Not at this time. Please place your orders for curbside pickup or delivery.

Question 4

Do you offer options for special dietary needs?

Accepted Answer

Yes, we cater to special dietary needs with vegan and gluten-free options. However, we currently do not offer sugar-free desserts.

Question 5

Do you provide delivery services? What areas do you cover and what are the costs?

Accepted Answer

Yes, we provide delivery services on a first-come, first-served basis. We deliver within a 30-mile radius of Highland, Indiana. Delivery fees start at $25 for local areas, $50+ for Chicago suburbs, and $75+ for Chicago.

Question 6

Meet ups?

Accepted Answer

No, please schedule a curbside pick up or delivery.

Question 7

Can I try your cakes before placing an order?

Accepted Answer

Yes, you can try our cakes before ordering! We offer a cupcake sample box where you can select up to three flavor and filling combinations to taste.

Question 8

When should I expect to hear from you?

Accepted Answer

Please allow 24-48 hours response time. This time may be longer during peak business days (Thursday-Saturday)

Question 9

Can you ship your cakes and desserts?

Accepted Answer

We currently do not offer shipping services for our cakes and desserts.

Question 10

Adult themed cakes?

Accepted Answer

We offer custom cakes for all events!

Welcome to Forever Bakery!

Frequently asked questions